Dr. C. Scott Ananian (cananian) wrote,
Dr. C. Scott Ananian

The return of magic.

Today's random discussion link is a piece in the Village Voice by Julian Dibbell, titled A Rape In Cyberspace. Don't fault him for the title, I'm sure it was his editor's. You'll have to read the whole thing to get to the bit I want to talk about, which is near the end.

The return of magic. Julian makes a case that we are returning to the age when speech made thing happen, directly and magically. (Any sufficiently advanced technology is indistinguishable from magic, etc, etc.) Our courts are now dealing with this (see the active cases at the EFF) in trying to determine in what parts a computer program (for now, just "words typed into a computer") is *expressive speech* (which gets 1st amendment protection) versus *functional speech* (which does not). Julian sees a future in which the First Amendment becomes increasingly untenable, because the Magic Word makes it so dangerous for words to be freely spoken.

It's an interesting idea, with an interesting perspective on our current legal troubles. I suddenly see myself and my entire community of programmers as *magicians* pleading vigourously for the right to speak against a society which is more and more afraid of what effects our words may wreak. And what, when we are *all* magicians? What laws govern then?

  • On Dog Parks In Somerville

    Perry Park in Somerville is being renovated; there were plans to include an off-leash recreational area for dogs in the renovation. The abutting…

  • The RebDog goes home...

    ...or rather, she is home already! I'll let Jessica tell the story: So after reading her bio (which of course, I wrote) and a few days of…

  • Baby Goes Home

    Our first foster greyhound, Baby Go (racing name "Go Go Baby Go"), was adopted yesterday morning by a charming woman (and her mom) who are certain…

  • Post a new comment


    Anonymous comments are disabled in this journal

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded